Last Week on Inked Brownies

Daughter of Sand and Stone by Libbie Hawker

daughter of sand and stone

Kindle Edition, 328 pages
Published December 1st,2015 by Lake Union Publishing

I figured since I studied history and Arabic, I would really dig this book. Like, REALLY. After reading it, all I can say it that I liked it, but it didn’t offer me the greatness I was expecting.

The Goodreads Synopsis:

Zenobia, the proud daughter of a Syrian sheikh, refuses to marry against her will. She won’t submit to a lifetime of subservience. When her father dies, she sets out on her own, pursuing the power she believes to be her birthright, dreaming of the Roman Empire’s downfall and her ascendance to the throne.

Defying her family, Zenobia arranges her own marriage to the most influential man in the city of Palmyra. But their union is anything but peaceful—his other wife begrudges the marriage and the birth of Zenobia’s son, and Zenobia finds herself ever more drawn to her guardsman, Zabdas. As war breaks out, she’s faced with terrible choices.

From the decadent halls of Rome to the golden sands of Egypt, Zenobia fights for power, for love, and for her son. But will her hubris draw the wrath of the gods? Will she learn a “woman’s place,” or can she finally stake her claim as Empress of the East?

The first third or so of the book is great. It has everything you want from an Arabic history story: jasmine, musk, camels, sand, veils, honey, figs, swords, nightly ambushes in the desert and a more realistic version of Aladdin-romance. In fact, I was singing this in my head a lot while reading Part 1 (the English version that is, this Arabic version is just cool for display):

When the story jumped ahead in time to Part 2, I already felt a bit disappointed, not having learned more about the time interval in between. However, when the book makes another time jump to Part 3, I became truly disappointed. Zenobia’s husband dies and woop, we’re at the part where she sits on the Egyptian throne (these aren’t any real spoilers by the way because they are historical facts). There are explanations here and there, telling us how she got to that point, but I would’ve loved to read about it directly instead.

Unlike Cleopatra, Zenobia is a less well-known figure by the average person, but nonetheless just as impressive: the second woman who took Egypt out of the hands of the Roman empire. Not a great deal of information on Zenobia has survived the hands of time but enough to create a general chronological line of events. Libbie Hawker filled up the rest between those lines with a fictional story. She did a good job most of the time, yet I just couldn’t get sucked into it like I hoped I would.

Zenobia is a very arrogant and unlikeable person. Maybe she had to be this way to become such a powerful woman and conquer Alexandria, but it makes the reading experience a lot less pleasant if you just can’t sympathize with the main character. At one point, when camel droppings hit the fan for her, I could only think ‘serves her right’.
Denying the love of her life, neglecting her son, ignoring all common sense and feeling delusionally superior don’t make her a loveable person, really.

What’s cool, though, is that the powerful male characters that surround her (Roman emperor Aurelian, her first husband Odaenathus (governor of Palmyra), and Zabdas, personal bodyguard and general of Zenobia’s army) all have great respect for women due to Zenobia herself. Plus, I have to admit, it’s pretty impressive to look at her Palmyrene empire here:

 

I ended up giving this book 3 stars. With a 100 pages more and/or a more relatable protagonist, this could’ve been a higher rating. Now it just feels like some great historical fiction has been cramped up in the length of an average YA-novel.

As an extra note, I’d like to mention that Palmyra, the city of Zenobia’s heart, the reason for most of her actions, has been taken by IS in 2015. The despicable assholes destroyed several ancient temples and other buildings there and by doing so, erasing 2000-year-old tangible history from the face of the earth. GG.

An ARC of this book was provided by the Lake Union Publishing via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review

brownie2brownie2brownie2

 

 

Links to the book:

Amazon US
Amazon UK
Goodreads

About Anne (231 Articles)
Dutch book reviewer who reviews in English. Grammar nazis beware!! I like brownies. And chamomile tea.

9 Comments on Daughter of Sand and Stone by Libbie Hawker

  1. Great review with some awesome additional collateral and facts by yourself. It made the whole thing so much more interesting to me to read about the IS fact (and yes, if there’s one thing that really broke my heart is that all those historical buildings are getting destroyed!)…

    I am guessing, with your knowledge and interest in the Arabic, you have also read The Arabian Nights: One Thousand and One Nights?

    Liked by 1 person

    • Merci! It just felt like a punch in the gut reading about Palmyra in its glorious peak days, knowing it was still being kept largely intact, and then IS comes and wreaks havoc there as well. They even used parts of the old city as a background for their beheading video’s…

      I have to shamefully admit that I never read the full thing! 🙂 A lot of the stories are just downright brutal and/or insane, so I skipped those back in the day. I’m probably still going to buy a nice copy of it some day, with a decent modern translation ^^. Have you read it yourself?

      Liked by 1 person

      • The Arabian Nights… heh, I have a really old worn out paperback back in my Estonian home… I have a vague memory of flipping through it as a child but obvs back then it didn’t make much sense, or I just blocked it out! haha… I have always thought I need to give this a go again, so, as yourself, I will probably look into getting my hands on it some time in the future 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

        • Is it lying next to the Satanic Bible there? 😉 Cheers on our semi quest of finding a copy that isn’t ridiculously expensive!

          Liked by 1 person

          • Haha… nope, the Satanic Bibles are with me in Ireland 😀 Keep the valuables close, and what not!

            Ooh, I haven’t checked out the prices… I don’t know if I want to now, that you’ve mentioned it! Are you looking for a copy in English or Dutch?

            Liked by 1 person

            • Hahaha 😀 They’d be a perfect couple standing next to each other on a bookshelf, though! I don’t think a normal version is that bad. I hope. But I want a hardcover leatherbound one fo sho ^^. No preference for English or Dutch with this one. I wanted to put this vid up at first btw: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1gFf7A1eg2I ,but thought it was more something of a personal fav. You might be able to appreciate it, though 😀

              Liked by 1 person

            • Ah yeah, gotta love the metal cover! Daycent! 🙂

              Like

  2. Olivia-Savannah // 19/01/2016 at 06:58 // Reply

    I’m glad you were able to enjoy the book, but it’s a shame that it couldn’t grab you that little bit much more. I like the idea of it and all, but when there is a big time jump in a novel it usually disappoints me a little. Especially if you feel like it has come a little too soon! I don’t think I am going to be reading this one, but it was good to discover it 😀

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: